Shorts vs Reels for Creators

published on 01 April 2024

Choosing between YouTube Shorts and Instagram Reels for your content? Here's what you need to know:

  • YouTube Shorts are 60-second videos that leverage YouTube's vast audience, offering features like auto-captions and video stitching. Though direct monetization is limited, the YouTube Shorts Fund and cross-promotion offer revenue opportunities.
  • Instagram Reels allow for up to 90-second videos, integrating seamlessly with Instagram's features like music library and special effects. Monetization mainly comes through ads, branded content, and driving traffic to monetizable platforms.
  • Both platforms cater to massive audiences (YouTube with over 2 billion and Instagram with over 1 billion monthly active users) but have different content preferences and engagement strategies.

Quick Comparison:

Feature YouTube Shorts Instagram Reels
Max Video Length 60 seconds 90 seconds
Audience 2+ billion monthly users, more male 1+ billion monthly users, balanced gender distribution
Monetization Shorts Fund, Partner Program, Tips Ads, Branded content, Affiliate links
Engagement Moderate, with a focus on expanding reach High, with a focus on trends and community

Ultimately, the best choice depends on your content style, audience, and monetization goals. Consider using both platforms strategically to maximize your reach and earnings.

Key Features

YouTube Shorts lets you make quick videos that are up to 60 seconds long. These videos are perfect for watching on your phone and are meant to be enjoyed fast.

Being a part of YouTube means these videos can get suggested to a lot of people. YouTube has billions of users, so your videos could be seen by way more people than on other apps that have short videos.

When making a YouTube Short, you can:

  • Let YouTube add captions for you
  • Put several clips together
  • Use filters and make your video look nicer
  • Add videos you've already taken

Audience and Content

YouTube Shorts is for everyone on YouTube, which is a lot of people (over 2 billion every month). This means your videos could be watched by a huge number of people.

The best types of videos for YouTube Shorts are ones that are quick to watch but really interesting or fun. You can make videos about almost anything, like funny moments, quick tips, recipes, dances, and more.

Monetization Opportunities

Right now, you can't make money directly from your Shorts like you can with longer YouTube videos.

But, you can still earn money in other ways, like:

  • YouTube Shorts Fund - A special fund that pays you if your Shorts get a lot of attention.
  • YouTube Partner Program - If you have more than 1,000 subscribers and your videos have been watched for over 4,000 hours in a year, you can make money from your longer videos.
  • Super Thanks - People can give you money if they really like your video.

So, even though you can't make money directly from Shorts, they're a good way to get more people to watch your other videos that can make money.

Understanding Instagram Reels

Key Features

Instagram Reels lets you make short videos up to 90 seconds long right inside Instagram. Here's what you can do:

  • Pick from a huge library of songs to add to your videos
  • Use cool tools like special effects, timers, and counters
  • Take sounds from other people's videos to make your own version
  • Share your Reels in your feed and they can also be found through search and tags

Audience and Content

Instagram Reels is for the huge crowd of over 1 billion people who use Instagram every month. It's perfect for making and sharing fun, short videos.

Here are some tips for Instagram Reels:

  • Shorter videos, like under 30 seconds, tend to get more people watching
  • Try out trendy songs, effects, and what's popular
  • Tag your videos with the right hashtags to help people find them
  • Ask viewers to like, comment, and share to reach even more people

Monetization Opportunities

Here's how you can make money with Instagram Reels:

  • Put ads in your Reels and get paid based on how many people see them
  • Use links to products or special shopping stickers in your videos
  • Send viewers to other places where you make money, like YouTube or websites
  • Grow your audience big enough and you might start making money directly from Instagram

Making money directly from Reels isn't a big thing yet, but you can use Reels to grow your audience and then guide them to where you can earn money.

Comparative Analysis

Content Length and Format

YouTube Shorts lets you make videos up to 60 seconds long. These are perfect for quick stories or sharing a bit of info. They're all about watching on the go.

Instagram Reels lets you go a bit longer, up to 90 seconds. This extra time can be great for certain videos, but shorter ones, like 15-30 seconds, usually get more people watching.

Platform Max Video Length Aspect Ratio
YouTube Shorts 60 seconds 9:16
Instagram Reels 90 seconds 9:16

Both let you play with editing, like adding cool effects or putting clips together. But YouTube can automatically add captions, which Instagram can't do yet.

Audience Reach and Engagement

YouTube Shorts is part of YouTube, which has a huge crowd of over 2 billion people every month. This means your videos could get seen by lots of people. Viewers might even check out your longer videos.

Instagram has over 1 billion people using it every month, and they really get into Reels. They like, comment, and share a lot. Instagram is also great for sending people to your website.

YouTube tends to have more guys watching, while Instagram has a more even mix of guys and girls. Instagram is also more popular with younger folks.

Platform Monthly Active Users Audience Split Engagement Level
YouTube 2+ billion More male viewers Moderate
Instagram 1+ billion Balanced male/female High

Monetization Opportunities

Making money directly from Shorts and Reels isn't as straightforward as with longer videos or regular posts. But both platforms offer ways to earn.

YouTube has a special fund for Shorts creators and other ways to make money, like getting tips from fans.

Instagram lets you make money through ads in your feed, and Reels can help you work with brands. You can also guide your followers to other places where you can earn, like your website or YouTube.

Platform Monetization Methods Earnings Potential
YouTube Shorts Ad revenue share, tips, cross-promotion Moderate
Instagram Reels Branded content, cross-promotion Moderate

In short, YouTube is great for reaching a lot of people but might not get as much interaction. Instagram is awesome for getting people involved and is good for working with brands. Both are good for sharing your content elsewhere to make money. Choosing the right one depends on who you want to reach and how you want to make money.


Strategic Considerations for Creators

Picking the best platform for your short videos is a big deal. It can really affect how well your content does and if you reach your goals. Here's what to think about when choosing between YouTube Shorts and Instagram Reels:

Content Style and Creativity

YouTube has more options for editing and mixing clips, while Instagram has lots of special effects and filters. Think about what kind of videos you want to make:

  • YouTube is good for sharing information, how-to guides, and specific hobbies. It has more editing tools.
  • Instagram is great for videos that grab attention with cool visuals, trends, and fun stuff. It has more effects.

Audience and Community

Think about who watches each platform and if they match your target audience:

  • YouTube has a huge, worldwide audience that's into all sorts of topics. There are strong groups for different interests.
  • Instagram tends to attract younger people and focuses more on lifestyle stuff. It has a big influencer scene.

See where your potential viewers hang out. Join groups on each platform to connect with them.

Goals and Monetization

Even though making money directly from Shorts and Reels is still developing, think about what you're aiming for:

  • Use YouTube to get people to watch your other videos that make money or visit your website. You might also get money from the Shorts Fund.
  • Instagram works well for partnerships, using affiliate links, and selling things. It's good for promoting your products.

Have clear goals and a plan for making money that fits how each platform works. Track how well you're doing based on those goals.

Cross-Platform Strategy

Think about sharing your content on both platforms to reach more people. But make sure to adjust your videos to suit each platform's strengths:

  • Share how-to guides on YouTube
  • Share moments from your life on Instagram

Use a tool to help schedule your posts on social media. Look at your data and how people engage with your content on each platform to figure out the best times to post. Change up your content based on what your audience likes best on each platform.

Choosing the right platform means knowing what kind of videos you make, what you want to achieve, and who you want to watch them. Tailor your approach for each platform and use both to grow your overall audience. Keep an eye on how well your content is doing and make changes as needed.


When trying to figure out if you should go with YouTube Shorts or Instagram Reels, think about a few important things:

Content Style and Goals

  • YouTube Shorts is great for videos that teach you something or explain how to do things. It has lots of tools for editing your videos.
  • Instagram Reels is all about quick, eye-catching videos that are fun or show off lifestyle stuff.

Audience and Community

  • YouTube is huge and has all kinds of people watching videos on tons of topics. It's also got groups for just about everything.
  • Instagram is more about younger folks and is big on trends and influencers.

Monetization and Marketing

  • YouTube lets you make some money from Shorts and also from other videos that have ads.
  • Instagram is really good for linking to products in your videos and working with brands.

Cross-Platform Strategy

  • Share how-to videos on YouTube and fun or lifestyle videos on Instagram.
  • Use tools to help you post at the right times and keep an eye on how your videos are doing.
  • Make sure your videos fit what each platform's users like.

Think about what kind of videos you make, who you want to watch them, and how you plan to make money. Whether you pick YouTube Shorts or Instagram Reels, look at what works best for your audience on each platform.

Which is better reels or Shorts?

Choosing between Shorts and Reels depends on what you need. Shorts lets you make videos up to 60 seconds with clearer and sharper video quality. Reels, on the other hand, lets you make longer videos up to 90 seconds. Each has its own benefits.

How much YouTube Shorts pay for 1,000 views?

Earning money from YouTube Shorts isn't very high. Generally, creators get about $0.05 to $0.07 for every thousand views. This means if your video gets a million views, you might earn between $50 to $70.

What are the disadvantages of Shorts on YouTube?

There are a few downsides to making YouTube Shorts:

  • They don't make much money from ads because they're too short for ads to run on them.
  • You can't search for Shorts like you can with longer videos.
  • They might not help you grow your channel in the long run.
  • They don't show up in the suggested videos section.

Is it better to make YouTube Shorts or videos?

If you're looking to get more watch time for monetization, only the watch time from longer videos counts. However, Shorts can be a great way to get more subscribers and reach a lot of viewers quickly.

Related posts

Read more